New research on 567 couples identifies three honesty profiles. The largest group — 48% — are "Strategic Soothers": they conceal mistakes, sidestep conflict, and say everything's fine when it isn't. They're not manipulating anyone. But they're still measurably less satisfied than partners who don't do this.
The study, published this week by Tim Cole of DePaul University in both Personal Relationships and the Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, began by mapping why people lie to their partners. Seven motives emerged — from conflict avoidance and sparing feelings, to covering up mistakes and avoiding physical intimacy. The team then used statistical modeling to see if people cluster into types.
Three came out clearly: Transparent Partners (38%) rarely deceive and report the highest relationship satisfaction. Strategic Soothers (48%) lie mainly to maintain harmony — they score low on dark personality traits and aren't trying to hurt anyone; they're just trying to keep things stable. Antagonistic Strategists (14%) endorse the full range of motives including intentionally causing harm, and report the lowest satisfaction and most frequent deception of all three groups.
What surprised even the researchers: Strategic Soothers and Antagonistic Strategists had nearly identical levels of attachment insecurity. The difference wasn't how anxious they were about the relationship — it was whether they had dark personality traits. "Attachment insecurity alone doesn't explain harmful deception," Cole noted.
The gap in satisfaction between Strategic Soothers and Transparent Partners was real. "Their deception may help keep the peace," Cole wrote, "but it doesn't eliminate the relationship costs associated with attachment insecurity."
For new parents running on empty, the Strategic Soother profile fits almost too well: you don't say you're resentful, you don't say you feel unseen, you don't say you're exhausted — because what's the point of another hard conversation tonight? The data says: the point is a lot.
Source: Cole & Stonebrook — Personal Relationships & Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, 2026 · via PsyPost, July 4, 2026
Keep readingDead bedroom after a baby: how to fix it without pressure · Lonely as a new dad? Why it happens and what helps · How relationships work — the crisis map · How to be a better husband after the baby
Co-founder of Regular. Writes about relationships, parenthood, and the science of how couples stay close after a baby.
About Regular — the relationship app for new dads, built by a small team of parents who needed it themselves. Small, science-backed moves with your partner, not big talks.